New Cookie Flavors
The expansion of new cookie flavors at Jersey Mike’s is an evolution of our Signature Chocolate Chunk Cookie, transforming it from a standalone product into a versatile platform with a focus on seasonal LTO’s and evergreen flavors.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
The Oatmeal Cranberry Raisin Cookie is our new evergreen dessert offering—crafted with hearty oats, juicy raisins, tart cranberries, and rich brown butter for a soft, chewy, nostalgic bite. It’s a premium, non-chocolate cookie designed to round out our dessert platform with variety and craveability. It gives us a complete cookie lineup—hero (chocolate chip), core variety (oatmeal cranberry raisin), and seasonal excitement (LTOs)—all while maximizing add-on revenue and satisfying more guests.
Fills a key flavor gap to offer a year-round, non-chocolate option for guests who want something warm, fruity, and familiar.
Oatmeal-based cookies are a proven seller and are the #2 best-sellers in foodservice behind chocolate chip.
Compliments our signature cookie by balancing our platform and sets the stage for rotating LTOs to drive dessert reappraisal and frequency.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Indulge in a classic cookie reimagined with premium ingredients and rich, nostalgic flavor. A soft, chewy masterpiece crafted with hearty Quaker Oats for that signature wholesome texture, and infused with Jersey Mike’s signature brown butter, delivering a warm, caramelized depth in every bite. Juicy raisins are folded into the dough for natural sweetness, perfectly balanced by the nutty richness of slow-cooked brown butter.
Delivered to Store Cost / Cookie: $0.37